IMBRA: Anatomy of a feminist hoax… your thoughts on IMBRA?
IMBRA: Anatomy of a feminist hoax
Carey Roberts Carey Roberts
September 26, 2007
Want a textbook example how the Left manufactures a crisis, passes a law that rolls back Constitutional protections, snookers card-carrying conservatives, and bilks American taxpayers? Look no farther than IMBRA, the International Marriage Broker Regulation Act.
A little background: It’s no secret that conditions in post-socialist Russia are grim. Author Sonya Luehrmann recounts how women desperately search to find a husband "to put one’s personal life in order, to settle down with a stable family."
And here in the United States, some men find American ladies to be a little too, shall we say, high-maintenance for their tastes.
Before long over 200 match-making services around the world had sprouted up like a clutch of springtime tulips.
A few years ago University of Pittsburgh professor Nicole Constable set out to probe the inner workings of these dating agencies. In her book Romance on a Global Stage, Constable revealed the international match-makers were simply responding to a human need for companionship and love. Many men who marry foreign brides "went to great lengths to ensure their partner’s comfort and happiness in the United States," she noted.
But feminists are rankled by any hint that their nostrum for female liberation may be curtailing American women’s marriage prospects. Worse, some of these foreign women actually aspire to be mothers and homemakers. Imagine that!
So the Sourpuss Sisters conspired to put the kibosh on the operation. They knew convincing Congress to regulate romance would be a hard sell. So they resorted to their tried and true formula of hackneyed stereotypes, outright demagoguery, and appeals to male chivalry.
It was Senator Maria Cantwell of Washington who quarterbacked the legislative strategy. First she brandished the notion of "mail-order brides," casting foreign women as victims of predatory males. Then she dubbed international dating services as "marriage brokers," conjuring up the image of a rogue operation trading lives for dollars.
On July 13, 2004 the Senate Foreign Relations Committee scheduled a hearing to air the issue. No dating services or happily-betrothed foreign women were invited to testify — their comments would not likely fit the script.
During her testimony, Cantwell made the startling claim that match-making services serve as a nefarious front for international human trafficking. She concluded, "there is a growing epidemic of domestic abuse among couples who meet via international marriage brokers." As proof of that "epidemic," she highlighted the cases of three abused women.
Cantwell’s depiction of comely maidens being seduced into prostitution rings was more than Sen. Sam Brownback could resist, and before long he signed on as a leading co-sponsor of the International Marriage Broker Regulation Act. With liberals and conservatives now on board, IMBRA’s political star was rising.
But it turns out that Senator Cantwell’s supposition that dating services drag women into a life of sex slavery and indentured servitude was nothing more than a feminist tall-tale.
There was the U.S. Immigration and Naturalization Service report that revealed, "less than 1 percent of the abuse cases now being brought to the attention of the INS can be attributed to the mail-order bride industry." [http://www.uscis.gov/portal/site/uscis/menuitem.5af9bb95919f35e66f614176543f6d1a/?vgnextoid=9ba5d0676988d010VgnVCM10000048f3d6a1RCRD&vgnextchannel=2c039c7755cb9010VgnVCM10000045f3d6a1RCRD]
A second analysis soberly concluded that foreign brides are "dramatically less likely to be involved in domestic violence as calculated by the Intimate Partner Murder Rate." [www.online-dating-rights.com/forum/index.php?topic=544.0]
And earlier this week the Washington Post reported that early estimates of up to 100,000 human trafficking victims being secreted into the United States each year were grossly exaggerated. Despite more than 0 million of taxpayer dollars diverted to a massive search and rescue effort, it turns out the actual number of trafficking victims is closer to 200 annually. [www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20929223]
But in the politically-correct atmosphere that envelopes Washington these days, agendas count for more than the truth.
So after the gavel fell on the Senate hearing, the International Marriage Broker Regulation Act was bundled into the Violence Against Women Act. That law was signed into law on January 5, 2006. A few days later, Fox News columnist Wendy McElroy castigated the act as branding all American men as "abusers." [www.ifeminists.net/introduction/editorials/2006/0111.html]
Now, any man who wishes to go through an international dating company must submit to an extensive background check. That’s right, guys, get ready to tell them about your arrests, criminal history, restraining orders, how many times you’ve been married, and even how many children you have. For good measure, don’t forget the sex offender registry check.
So thanks to Senator Cantwell’s artful dissembling and Senator Brownback’s white-horse chivalry, men are presumed to be a threat to foreign women. And Cupid’s arrow now falls under the watchful eyes of green-visored bureaucrats.
http://www.renewamerica.us/columns/roberts/070926
- What do guys think about girls they met on dating sites? Sometimes I get a feeling that I should not meet any men from dating sites. I did not have much good experience. Some business men I met seemed to have treated me like as if I am an escort service than a girl friend. I guess it depends on people......
- how long will my package take to clear US customs, I called USPS about it and the lady was so rude about it...? Service Type: International Parcels Shipment Activity Location Date & Time -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Inbound Into Customs UNITED STATES 06/05/09 10:19am Inbound International ISC SAN FRANCISCO (USPS) 06/05/09 10:18am Arrival Foreign International HONG KONG 06/02/09 1:40pm Dispatch Origin Post is HONG KONG 06/02/09 3:19am Preparing Shipment Foreign Acceptance HONG KONG 06/01/09 12:56pm --------------------------------------------------------------------------------......
- How to get the guy? Date advice, Tips, tricks, Flirting Techniques? Hey okay SOOOO lets cut to the chase Met a guy, he had a HUGE party at his house, i went with some friends, I ended up dancing with him about 4 times. definitely flirty then about a week later he texts me and asks if when he gets back......
- Has anyone ever heard of a cell phone dating network called lifestyles? My friend who is single and just turning 50 is chatting with strange men on a phone dating line. It is a swinging singles cybersex line. I'm concerned for her safety. I met my husband online but I checked his background before I would ever meet him. I've heard of......
- US Postal Service:Registered Mail has not reached sender,for 38 days now? I had an important document register posted from Longmont,Colorado to Singapore.It cost US & 38 days to this day and it has not reached yet.Tracking on the USPS web shows it reached San Francisco's International Mail centre 12 days later!!! A normal mail would have reached the far east in......
- Upcoming military draft: Universal National Service Act of 2006 I had heard a while ago of a new bill in the House that would require all people in the United States, including women, between the ages of 18 and 42 to perform a period of military service or a period of civilian service for homeland security. I had forgotten......
- Top VoIP Companies There are many VoIP companies located in the United States of America. Some of these VoIP companies include Vonage, SBC, PointOne Inc., and Time Warner Cable. These companies that provide VoIP services to people allow people to save money on their phone bills.There are things about each one of......
- US Open Tennis Series Recap Here is a look at the current standings for the US Open Tennis Series which is rolling along this week as we get closer to the final tournament, where millions of dollars are at stake. Men's Current Standings 1 - Andy Murray from Britain, is currently holding a score of......
- Online Dating Has Turned Into A Huge Industry. During the last years online dating sites replaced newsprint personals since dating sites become more and more popular among the users. Even though there are different types of these sites the majority of them is senior dating sites. Some of them are free of charge and do not require any......
- Single Life - For Girls Only Does having a long term partner really bring the rewards we hear about, and does being hooked up give us that certainty of feeling secure? Initially yes, but according to recent London relationships publications, many couples find themselves at a lower level of happiness in the long run. So many......
Filed under: Single Dating Services
Gee, I’m so disappointed Sam Brokeback’s presidential campaign was DOA. </sarcasm>
And don’t get me started on Maria Cantdo$&!+well.
The lesson American men may take is to move to where the foreign women are instead of bringing them here. Fine by me.
Feminist lies about domestic violence are nothing new, sad to say e.g. the Super Bowl Sunday fiasco http://www.snopes.com/crime/statistics/superbowl.asp
The tragedy is that people remember the lie and forget the debunking, then go on to proudly call themselves feminists.
That’s funny cause I married out of my race so that I could be a stay at home mom; remember too that if push comes to shove I can work a full day and come home and do the laundry. Anyways more feminists blatant lying and forcing the bottle to spin their way; their new motto today is my way or the high way. What they’re saying is that all men are supposed to love strong independent women who don’t roll over to get their bellies scratched. So, now that they’ve found out the opposite; they don’t like it; not one little bit; like I said, "it’s their way or the highway.
Its funny how the major dating sites are extempt from it. I suspect its those major sites bashing the smaller competition using feminism as an excuse rather than a full blown feminist movement. Want to bypass IMBRA ? Just use match.com or the like.
"here in the United States, some men find American ladies to be a little too, shall we say, high-maintenance for their tastes."
Ahh…code for "misogynistic losers who can’t find doormats in the U.S., so they have to import them from countries with a low level of human rights, so they can at least get a woman to be a house slave for a few years, until she figures out that she doesn’t have to put up with being a doormat in this country."
Aren’t these the same kind of questions we answer on job applications or for adoptions? For major commitments, such as employment or parenting, don’t we regularly allow people to ask these kind of questions that will determine if we have a bad history? We don’t go around complaining about these questions on jobs applications, do we? These questions seem very reasonable if you are looking at matching people up for marriage. Just because we ask a questions doesn’t mean we assume the answer falls a particular way. Would you want to be married off to a serial rapist anyway?